The World of Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: An Overview
Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective is an iconic board game that invites players to step into the shoes of Sherlock Holmes and his team of sleuths to solve complex mysteries. Originally released in the 1980s, the game pioneered the genre of cooperative detective board games and quickly became a classic thanks to its unique combination of immersive storytelling, clever puzzles, and the feeling of real detective work. In this game, players read detailed newspaper articles, interrogate suspects, and follow clues across London to solve a case. It is a deep, non-linear experience that challenges players to reach conclusions on their own, without the aid of dice or cards. Several editions and expansions have been released over the years, each introducing new cases and challenges to solve.
The Best Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective Games
In this blog we'll discuss the different editions of Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective, ranked in order of popularity, and we'll also take a look at a game that uses the Sherlock System in a different, equally fascinating setting.
1. Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Baker Street Irregulars
The Baker Street Irregulars is one of the most beloved installments in the Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective series. In this edition, players take on the role of the Baker Street Irregulars, a group of young street urchins often employed by Holmes to gather information. This edition features ten unique cases that range in complexity and theme, making it suitable for both newcomers and seasoned detectives. The stories are meticulously written, with surprising twists and deep, intricate mysteries that invite players to investigate every detail. The Baker Street Irregulars offers a fresh take on the classic formula and is a must-have for fans of the genre.
2. Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: The Thames Murders & Other Cases
The Thames Murders & Other Cases is perhaps the most well-known edition of Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective, and for good reason. This set contains ten intriguing cases, including the infamous Thames Murders, where players must track down the killer who has London in his grip. This game is known for its challenging and in-depth cases that require a great deal of attention to detail. The complexity of the mysteries in this edition makes it a favorite among experienced players who enjoy a real brain-teasing challenge. The atmosphere of Victorian London is beautifully captured, and players will truly feel like detectives following in Holmes’ footsteps.
3. Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: Jack the Ripper & West End Adventures
Jack the Ripper & West End Adventures combines two very different but equally compelling sets of cases. The first half of the game focuses on the infamous Jack the Ripper murders, one of the most terrifying and puzzling series of murders in London's history. Players attempt to unmask the killer and stop the criminal's terrifying deeds. The second half, West End Adventures, contains a series of standalone adventures set in London's posh West End. These cases are less grim than Jack the Ripper's, but still offer plenty of challenge and excitement. This game is perfect for players who enjoy historical crime cases and variety in their mysteries.
4. Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective: Carlton House & Queen's Park
Carlton House & Queen's Park offers a unique twist to the Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective series by introducing a new setting: the majestic Carlton House. In this edition, players will encounter cases set within this stately mansion and the surrounding Queen's Park. Park. The setting itself plays a crucial role in solving the mysteries, with players having to carefully study the layout of Carlton House to unravel its secrets. This edition has been praised for its inventive use of space and its detailed, atmospheric storytelling. The is a great choice for players looking for a unique challenge within the Sherlock Holmes universe.
Bureau of Investigation: Mysteries in Arkham Horror
In addition to the Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective series, there is Bureau of Investigation , a game that applies the same detective mechanics to the dark and ominous world of Arkham Horror. In Bureau of Investigation , players take on the role of agents tasked with investigating supernatural occurrences and unexplained crimes in the HP Lovecraft-inspired Arkham. These cases are often more grim and supernatural in nature, creating a completely different atmosphere than the Sherlock Holmes games. Players must consider the unthinkable and navigate a web of mystery and horror. Bureau of Investigation offers an intense and suspenseful experience that is perfect for fans of both detective work and horror.
An unforgettable detective experience
Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective is more than a board game; it’s an immersive experience that challenges players to unravel the mystery as Sherlock Holmes would. With its compelling storytelling, intricate puzzles, and authentic atmosphere, the series remains one of the most beloved and respected games in its genre. Whether you choose to tackle the classic murder cases of The Thames Murders, the chilling Jack the Ripper cases, or the unique challenges of Carlton House, each game offers an unforgettable quest through Victorian London. And for those looking for a new challenge in a grittier universe, Bureau of Investigation perfectly complements the detective mechanics with its horror theme. Ready to tackle your next case? Then click on the bold links above to purchase your favorite Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective game or Bureau of Investigation and begin your next adventure!